What’s Up With Ghostbusters on PS3?

Let the flame wars begin. Gaming site Lensoftruth.com put the PS3 and Xbox 360 versions of Ghostbusters: The Video Game to the test in their comparative feature, "Head2Head," and the results were, if nothing else, definitive; the game simply looks way better on the Xbox 360.
According to the comparison, not only does the PS3 version run in “sub 720p” resolution, it also features significantly lower texture quality and noticeably weaker dynamic shadows. Even the burning ember effects on Proton Pack-damaged walls is missing in Sony’s version, leaving only dark grey lines instead. Making the PS3 edition even more unattractive is the mandatory 8 minute, 3.9gb install.
So what happened? Isn’t the PS3 supposed to be the more powerful system? Isn’t Ghostbusters a Sony property? Wasn’t the game supposed to be developed for the PS3, then adapted for the 360? Most importantly, weren’t we supposed to be done with inferior PS3 versions of games, like 2 years ago?
Well, despite remarks by Mark Randel, president of developer Terminal Reality, that “We're one of the few developers who love the PS3 and have a great time with it. We have great technology for the PS3 and we want to show it off,” and “If we’re doing a PS3 only game however, we could be doing a lot more. We could be pushing a lot more on the screen,” apparently, the PS3 is a somewhat inhospitable environment for the game’s Infernal Engine.
Joystiq asked Terminal Reality about the huge discrepancy, and was told “For the record, the PS3 version [of Ghostbusters] is softer due to the 'quincunx' anti-aliasing filter and the fact we render at about 75% the resolution of the 360 version. So you cannot directly compare a screen shot of one to the other unless you scale them properly. The PS3 does have less available RAM than the 360 – but we managed to squeeze 3 out of 4 textures as full size on the PS3."
While at first glance this may seem like an excuse for the PS3 version, Terminal Reality is basically saying that either the Infernal Engine, their proprietary game engine, can’t handle the PS3, or that the PS3 can’t handle their game engine. “Quincunx” filter aside, the developer can say what they want about scaling properly, but some of the PS3’s environmental textures are ¼ the resolution of the 360’s.
So basically, if you own both systems, there’s no reason to buy the PS3 version of Ghostbusters unless you’re big into mandatory installs and squinting. Now if you’ll excuse me, I’ll be covering my head to avoid the inevitable PS3/Xbox fanboy throwdown that’s about to kick off. Remember kids, keep it above the belt, and no rabbit punches.
- Comments
-
But... who do I call about this... Hm.
Coop
Sun, 21 June 2009 12:14AM
-
One could also argue that the blur effect makes it look more like the old movies and eliminate jaggies, thus making it more realistic. I highly doubt that a blur that severe is caused by enlarging an image only by 25%. (Assuming the image in this article isn't fabricated) There are details that are completely missing, like the bolts in the metal of the door. I believe it is safe to say that tiny details like this were actually completely removed from the PS3 release.
FemJesse
Thu, 18 June 2009 12:15PM
-
Damn you, Quincunx! Bane of my existence!
ozymandias
Thu, 18 June 2009 11:28AM
-
well boo to that.. but i doubt i'll care too much.
wolfkin
Thu, 18 June 2009 02:12AM
-
Sounds to me like they're saying that they would look the same if the PS3 shot was shrunk my 25%. Looks like it might be legit. Everything just looks a tad stretched on the left...
Either way, awesome game, right?
seanasaurus
Wed, 17 June 2009 10:52PM
-
I think I'm done arguing about this. Simply due to it being a developer's choice to do whatever it is that they decided to do. Everyone else can have fun prodding each other.
QMarc80
Wed, 17 June 2009 10:03PM
- Related Articles
-
-
- Ghostbusters Trailer Makes Me Happy
-
"We should split up..."Wed, 15 April 2009 11:44AM4 Comments
-
-
-
- Sony to Co-Publish PS Ghostbusters in Europe, PAL Regions
-
UPDATED: Timed Exclusivity ConfirmedWed, 06 May 2009 09:08AM4 Comments
-
-
-
- New Trailer Shows Off Gameplay
-
And doesn't look like garbage!Sat, 18 April 2009 06:51PM4 Comments
-
-
-
- Alyssa Milano Replacing Sigourney Weaver in Ghostbusters Game
-
Former Melrose Place Star to Voice New CharacterSat, 21 March 2009 04:07PM9 Comments
-
-
-
- Nintendo's Lackluster Piece of Crap
-
A Five Star Hotel, and a Point Five Star HotelSat, 13 June 2009 02:04PM12 Comments
-
Community